10 Evaluation Blocks
Comprehensive assessment criteria for thesis evaluation
1
15%Research Foundation
Theoretical and methodological groundwork
Evaluation Criteria:
- Literature Review
- Methodology
- Theoretical Framework
2
20%Architectural Concept
Core design philosophy and approach
Evaluation Criteria:
- Concept Development
- Design Philosophy
- Spatial Organization
3
15%Technical Execution
Implementation and technical details
Evaluation Criteria:
- Technical Details
- Construction Methods
- Material Selection
4
10%Innovation Quotient
Novelty and creative contributions
Evaluation Criteria:
- Originality
- Creativity
- Innovative Solutions
5
10%Contextual Integration
Environmental and contextual considerations
Evaluation Criteria:
- Site Analysis
- Context Response
- Environmental Integration
6
10%Sustainability Matrix
Environmental impact and sustainability
Evaluation Criteria:
- Energy Efficiency
- Environmental Impact
- Sustainable Practices
7
10%Documentation Quality
Presentation and documentation standards
Evaluation Criteria:
- Drawings Quality
- Report Structure
- Visual Communication
8
5%Practical Application
Real-world applicability and impact
Evaluation Criteria:
- Practical Implementation
- User Impact
- Social Relevance
9
3%Peer Review Score
External validation and peer assessment
Evaluation Criteria:
- Peer Feedback
- External Review
- Validation
10
2%Overall Coherence
Holistic integration and consistency
Evaluation Criteria:
- Project Unity
- Consistency
- Holistic Approach
Scoring Methodology
Each block is scored individually on a 0-100 scale, then weighted according to the specified percentages. The final score is calculated as the sum of all weighted block scores, determining the overall grading band.